FabGuys.com mobile

Already registered?
Login here

Back to forum list
Back to The Lounge

Whatever happened to agree to disagree

Jump to newest
 

By *orcester Guy OP   Man
3 weeks ago

Worcestershire North

During debates discussions etc

The common phrase was agree to disagree

Now all we hear is an ist or ism which effectively closes down a discussion for fear of being labelled

Don’t you think its why everything is so toxic and where we are now at in terms of pride trans asylum seekers politics etc

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *dambi00Man
3 weeks ago

Leicestershire

Issue is, on these forums people don’t really want to hear one another’s sides when ‘debating’, it’s more ‘you’re wrong, I’m right and that’s the end of it’

It’s pointless

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *3versMan
3 weeks ago

glasgow

If we just all agreed to disagree, or just let things go by that we don't agree with - what kind of society would we become?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *orcester Guy OP   Man
3 weeks ago

Worcestershire North


"If we just all agreed to disagree, or just let things go by that we don't agree with - what kind of society would we become?"

More respectful towards each other

Years ago guys would say he’s a decent bloke for a Tory or Man U supporter etc

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *3versMan
3 weeks ago

glasgow


"If we just all agreed to disagree, or just let things go by that we don't agree with - what kind of society would we become?

More respectful towards each other

Years ago guys would say he’s a decent bloke for a Tory or Man U supporter etc "

I'm going to have to disagree with you on that one - I think we'd become a society of bullies and mob rule

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *amarinMan
3 weeks ago

St Helens

Are we not heading that way now?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ensualblokeMan
3 weeks ago

Colchester

I think if you let the 'ist's and 'ism's bother you, then you have lost already. Stop giving a shit and it's very liberating!

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *dstefiMan
3 weeks ago

Solihull

On a forum all you really see is somebody's naked opinion, you can never know the full person.

I'm a proud leftie and woke to boot, but I know and work with Tory and even Reform supporters, even like some of them personally as nobody's two-dimensional. Sure some of the crap they spout boils my piss, but when it's in person one tends to moderate the responses. I'll still try to have a reasoned argument and put the other point of view across, but not get into a slanging match.

Online of course the rules of civility and personal decency that hold society together don't apply. What's disturbing is how much the online wild west lack of rules is creeping into flesh and blood society and real lives.

My wife's a secondary teacher and sees this every fucking day, teenagers who think their TikToks are society.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *eefandfurMan
3 weeks ago

Edinburgh

Throwing the ists or the isms just shows that they are incapable of debating. As soon as someone relies on personal insults, they have lost the argument.

We have a big problem with ideological tribalism.

All of the media outlets seem to have dropped intelligent debate and replaced it with 6 people on screen shouting over each other, further normalising low-information mud-slinging.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *3versMan
3 weeks ago

glasgow


"On a forum all you really see is somebody's naked opinion, you can never know the full person.

"

That's very insightful- I'm to try and use that

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *weddolMan
3 weeks ago

Chester

Agree to disagree works when you know the person and can put their beliefs into context.

But even then there are lines that can be crossed that make it impossible.

For example a man who believes in monogamy and that he is the head of the household, you can agree to disagree with on gender roles etc because you know him to be a good father and who works hard to keep his family life.

But if his views also include beating his wife black and blue for being too friendly with a neighbour, then he's crossed that line.

On the Internet you haven't got the context of what the person's life is.

I know people at work who I can agree to disagree with who hold similar views to people convicted of rioting and attempting to set fire to a building with people trapped inside. This I could not agree to disagree with.

2 different ends of a spectrum. With strangers on the Internet you have no idea where on that spectrum people are.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *weddolMan
3 weeks ago

Chester

There was a guy at work who was a bit of a sexist. But he was one of the guys, and you could be pally with him even though you disagreed (or not) with his attitude to women.

But he got the sack after assaulting a young girl in the warehouse, and suddenly nobody could agree to disagree with that.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *excessMan
3 weeks ago

Sleaford

It's the internets anonymity that enables people to offer their opinion rather than wait to be asked for it.

There's no comeback,like there is when your face to face with someone.

I see it all the time in these forums

Example

Forum post asking who likes lingerie.

Answer from some clam, I hate lingerie!!

Well noone asked you, that wasn't the question you numpty🙄

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ucker4you80Man
3 weeks ago

Calne


"Throwing the ists or the isms just shows that they are incapable of debating. As soon as someone relies on personal insults, they have lost the argument.

We have a big problem with ideological tribalism.

All of the media outlets seem to have dropped intelligent debate and replaced it with 6 people on screen shouting over each other, further normalising low-information mud-slinging. "

Hang on a minute, you are the first to throw insults around, you do it all the time when someone makes a point that you can't disagree with, you're horrendous to some people on here!

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *waff1102Man
3 weeks ago

King's Lynn, Norfolk

I fully agree with everything that's been said.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *waff1102Man
3 weeks ago

King's Lynn, Norfolk

I totally disagree with everything that's been said

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *orcester Guy OP   Man
3 weeks ago

Worcestershire North


"I totally disagree with everything that's been said"

Sit on the fence why don’t you

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ogwhammerMan
3 weeks ago

Rainham KENT

Agree to disagree agree is just a cop out

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *awsMan
3 weeks ago

Portsmouth


"On a forum all you really see is somebody's naked opinion, you can never know the full person.

I'm a proud leftie and woke to boot, but I know and work with Tory and even Reform supporters, even like some of them personally as nobody's two-dimensional. Sure some of the crap they spout boils my piss, but when it's in person one tends to moderate the responses. I'll still try to have a reasoned argument and put the other point of view across, but not get into a slanging match.

Online of course the rules of civility and personal decency that hold society together don't apply. What's disturbing is how much the online wild west lack of rules is creeping into flesh and blood society and real lives.

My wife's a secondary teacher and sees this every fucking day, teenagers who think their TikToks are society. "

So their conservative right leaning views are crap! They may think the same about the lefty crap you spout, so it goes both ways. So the OP original point is agree to disagree!

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ickeMan
3 weeks ago

watford

If I find my opinion is someone thick I tend to agree .

As one you won’t change their opinions.

2 if you try prove they are wrong, they are libel to prove your wrong by getting angry then violent.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *lex46TV/TS
3 weeks ago

Wells

I just agree with everything

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *hris4tvMan
3 weeks ago

liverpool

A few reasons but predominantly cultural shifts in how we're spoken too or information is conveyed to us...the masses.

Everything is polarised more... don't underestimate this. Its a terrible thing. Then add to that we view things on moral rather than practical terms. So everything is perceived as good v evil so tolerance of an ounce of it feels immoral. Best get rid of tolerance then.

Opinions are not just that anymore they tied to identity values and groups / tribes. Conceding means youre betraying your tribe. See this alot on here with cons bad labour good - its mind numbing.

Add the above to social media and a sprinkling of amplification and boom - discourse dies.

Mediation was typically found in workplaces church's civic space etc etc... as that form declines so does reasonable discourse.

This causes an erosion of respectful debate skills and increase in ad-hominim attacks.

So... disagreements are not like a coexistence of perspectives anymore but an actual real living breathing threat to your truth or pur morality and your identity.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ade crossTV/TS
3 weeks ago

chiselhurst

Forums are to full of keyboard warriors. Happy to sprout what ever crap they believe and rudely shout down any one who disagrees.

It's very easy to be faceless and hide in a forum.

I just don't bother with the rantings in these forums anymore. Be left or right wing.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *evanianMan
3 weeks ago

Flintshire


"During debates discussions etc

The common phrase was agree to disagree

Now all we hear is an ist or ism which effectively closes down a discussion for fear of being labelled

Don’t you think its why everything is so toxic and where we are now at in terms of pride trans asylum seekers politics etc "

It's interesting to note how discussions have changed over time. We used to be able to agree to disagree, but now it feels like labelling and shaming have become more prevalent.

When people worry about being slapped with an "ism" or having their views dismissed, it can really stifle open and honest conversation. This can have a ripple effect, impacting all sorts of topics from politics to social issues.

I've also noticed that some people, despite being very capable, often rely on strong language and expletives to make their point.

But this approach can actually undermine their message, making them seem less articulate or in control. Maybe that's just another one of those things we'll have to agree to disagree on!

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *eefandfurMan
3 weeks ago

Edinburgh


"Throwing the ists or the isms just shows that they are incapable of debating. As soon as someone relies on personal insults, they have lost the argument.

We have a big problem with ideological tribalism.

All of the media outlets seem to have dropped intelligent debate and replaced it with 6 people on screen shouting over each other, further normalising low-information mud-slinging.

Hang on a minute, you are the first to throw insults around, you do it all the time when someone makes a point that you can't disagree with, you're horrendous to some people on here! "

If six separate people disagree with you, maybe it's time for some introspection.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ucker4you80Man
3 weeks ago

Calne


"Throwing the ists or the isms just shows that they are incapable of debating. As soon as someone relies on personal insults, they have lost the argument.

We have a big problem with ideological tribalism.

All of the media outlets seem to have dropped intelligent debate and replaced it with 6 people on screen shouting over each other, further normalising low-information mud-slinging.

Hang on a minute, you are the first to throw insults around, you do it all the time when someone makes a point that you can't disagree with, you're horrendous to some people on here!

If six separate people disagree with you, maybe it's time for some introspection. "

Nope, people disagreeing makes no difference to a thing that is true, it's just people being petty and spiteful. This forum is like a pissing contest for a few characters that get a kick out of verbally beating people up, it's disgusting.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *speedoMan
3 weeks ago

eastbourne

An entire generation are puzzled by the idea that anyone has the right to say things they don't agree with

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ayPonty1Man
3 weeks ago

Pontypridd

It ended with Social Media and a generation who have been told that they are always right.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *obert xMan
3 weeks ago

West Lancs


"An entire generation are puzzled by the idea that anyone has the right to say things they don't agree with"

Brought up wrapped in cotton wool, rarely told "no", surrounded by those who agree with them. Then unleashed into the wild. What could possibly go wrong?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *0yguyMan
3 weeks ago

Cumberland

It’s interesting that it is reported that at the Edinburgh festival the comedy award was given for the time to a transgender comedian. There was no mention that they were white, or that they had a visual disability (they wore glasses). It seems that the woke and opinion pendulum swings in different directions.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *eefandfurMan
3 weeks ago

Edinburgh


"An entire generation are puzzled by the idea that anyone has the right to say things they don't agree with

Brought up wrapped in cotton wool, rarely told "no", surrounded by those who agree with them. Then unleashed into the wild. What could possibly go wrong?"

Combined with a 'knowledge' based on a tweet or whatever is trending, swallowed and believed without question or any independent investigation.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *dambi00Man
3 weeks ago

Leicestershire


"An entire generation are puzzled by the idea that anyone has the right to say things they don't agree with

Brought up wrapped in cotton wool, rarely told "no", surrounded by those who agree with them. Then unleashed into the wild. What could possibly go wrong?

Combined with a 'knowledge' based on a tweet or whatever is trending, swallowed and believed without question or any independent investigation. "

Don’t think this is a generational thing, plenty of older men in these forums throw buzz words out when you disagree with them, even if you send sources and facts. An example being the Lucy Connolly thread, a guy who was 70 said she didn’t commit any crime, I cited the crime and what law she broke, and the fact she pleaded guilty, he then called me a woke leftist in my messages.

Isn’t a generational thing at all.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *laireKTV/TS
3 weeks ago

Manchester

In this country we can still hold opinions which differ, as long as we are respectful.

If we don't understand how valuable that is, just try going to a country which will punish you for religious views you express.

I never ever want that here. If the price is to listen to people you disagree with, then fine.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *eefandfurMan
3 weeks ago

Edinburgh


"An entire generation are puzzled by the idea that anyone has the right to say things they don't agree with

Brought up wrapped in cotton wool, rarely told "no", surrounded by those who agree with them. Then unleashed into the wild. What could possibly go wrong?

Combined with a 'knowledge' based on a tweet or whatever is trending, swallowed and believed without question or any independent investigation.

Don’t think this is a generational thing, plenty of older men in these forums throw buzz words out when you disagree with them, even if you send sources and facts. An example being the Lucy Connolly thread, a guy who was 70 said she didn’t commit any crime, I cited the crime and what law she broke, and the fact she pleaded guilty, he then called me a woke leftist in my messages.

Isn’t a generational thing at all. "

Yes more of a social media/ online generation thing, rather than an age thing. People would act more courteously if meeting IRL whatever their age.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *dambi00Man
3 weeks ago

Leicestershire


"An entire generation are puzzled by the idea that anyone has the right to say things they don't agree with

Brought up wrapped in cotton wool, rarely told "no", surrounded by those who agree with them. Then unleashed into the wild. What could possibly go wrong?

Combined with a 'knowledge' based on a tweet or whatever is trending, swallowed and believed without question or any independent investigation.

Don’t think this is a generational thing, plenty of older men in these forums throw buzz words out when you disagree with them, even if you send sources and facts. An example being the Lucy Connolly thread, a guy who was 70 said she didn’t commit any crime, I cited the crime and what law she broke, and the fact she pleaded guilty, he then called me a woke leftist in my messages.

Isn’t a generational thing at all.

Yes more of a social media/ online generation thing, rather than an age thing. People would act more courteously if meeting IRL whatever their age. "

Yeah for sure, during my masters degree we had a lot of debate classes, the debates were actually source based and people were respectful, whereas on here or the internet in general, people become very nasty towards one another.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *eefandfurMan
3 weeks ago

Edinburgh


"

Yeah for sure, during my masters degree we had a lot of debate classes, the debates were actually source based and people were respectful, whereas on here or the internet in general, people become very nasty towards one another. "

Formal debating is a very useful skill, it should be compulsory, and taught in all schools.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *dstefiMan
3 weeks ago

Solihull


"In this country we can still hold opinions which differ, as long as we are respectful.

If we don't understand how valuable that is, just try going to a country which will punish you for religious views you express.

I never ever want that here. If the price is to listen to people you disagree with, then fine."

You make a good point. However a line has to be drawn about freedom of expression e.g. "I think there are too many people from other countries coming to the UK", which is acceptable even if sufficient people think it to elect a large number of Reform MPs.

Overtly racist thuggery and incitement to violence and death to immigrants such as what Lucy Connolly got rightly done for and which Tommy fucking Yaxley Lennon keeps evading just actually smacks of those very countries you complain about though. Let it go far enough and we could easily have a christo-fascist state. It doesn't take much to make a concerned person into a raving gammon.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *haron1701ETV/TS
3 weeks ago

Southport


"An entire generation are puzzled by the idea that anyone has the right to say things they don't agree with

Brought up wrapped in cotton wool, rarely told "no", surrounded by those who agree with them. Then unleashed into the wild. What could possibly go wrong?"

Bloody everything unfortunately

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *haron1701ETV/TS
3 weeks ago

Southport


"

Yeah for sure, during my masters degree we had a lot of debate classes, the debates were actually source based and people were respectful, whereas on here or the internet in general, people become very nasty towards one another.

Formal debating is a very useful skill, it should be compulsory, and taught in all schools. "

100% agree with that

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *orcester Guy OP   Man
3 weeks ago

Worcestershire North


"An entire generation are puzzled by the idea that anyone has the right to say things they don't agree with

Brought up wrapped in cotton wool, rarely told "no", surrounded by those who agree with them. Then unleashed into the wild. What could possibly go wrong?"

I think you make a valid point

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *orcester Guy OP   Man
3 weeks ago

Worcestershire North


"In this country we can still hold opinions which differ, as long as we are respectful.

If we don't understand how valuable that is, just try going to a country which will punish you for religious views you express.

I never ever want that here. If the price is to listen to people you disagree with, then fine.

You make a good point. However a line has to be drawn about freedom of expression e.g. "I think there are too many people from other countries coming to the UK", which is acceptable even if sufficient people think it to elect a large number of Reform MPs.

Overtly racist thuggery and incitement to violence and death to immigrants such as what Lucy Connolly got rightly done for and which Tommy fucking Yaxley Lennon keeps evading just actually smacks of those very countries you complain about though. Let it go far enough and we could easily have a christo-fascist state. It doesn't take much to make a concerned person into a raving gammon. "

Threatening to harm needs to be dealt with in correct manner but also in context

How many times did your dad say I’m gonna kill you ? Did he ever end up in Parkhurst?

Honest debate has been closed down from the top

Remember Gordon Brown slagging that woman off camera ?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *dstefiMan
3 weeks ago

Solihull


"How many times did your dad say I’m gonna kill you ? Did he ever end up in Parkhurst?"

Again false equivalence and whataboutery. My dad a) didn't and b) even if he had, wasn't broadcasting it to thousands of followers looking for any excuse to beat me up.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *q oralistMan
3 weeks ago

Torquay

I agree with the American humorist who said "I rather went off the human race when I realised how very much like me they all are"

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *laireKTV/TS
3 weeks ago

Manchester

You see more people in the US making direct comment on social media channels now, about UK affairs. They are obviously getting info direct from specific people with an agenda.

Americans can say a lot more than we can, without consequence.

Maybe that's the future . Debate by proxy?

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ookingaroundMan
3 weeks ago

Bristol


"

Brought up wrapped in cotton wool, rarely told "no", surrounded by those who agree with them. Then unleashed into the wild. What could possibly go wrong?"

Said every older generation about the younger generation ever since humans began.

And every time they said “yea but that generation is especially bad for (insert reason here)”

And it will happen to that generation as they start to wane in social relevance too.

We just need the self awareness to understand what we think about each other is not unique, it happened before and will happen again. It’s us, not them.

Although, yea, this time it’s different…🤣

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *hyna HutchMan
3 weeks ago

valleys

It's just like a load of blokes in a bar having verbal.

.....only with their cocks hanging out.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ookingaroundMan
3 weeks ago

Bristol


"It's just like a load of blokes in a bar having verbal.

.....only with their cocks hanging out."

You must drink it classier bars than me if that is the differentiating factor for you. 😂

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *eekingcumsMan
3 weeks ago

Stoke/Stafford

It all disappeared with the anonymity of the Internet.

Where being an objectionable cunt, gives you somewhere to hide.

Where as face to face (in the workplace or in a bar) is somewhat different.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ucker4you80Man
3 weeks ago

Calne


"

Brought up wrapped in cotton wool, rarely told "no", surrounded by those who agree with them. Then unleashed into the wild. What could possibly go wrong?

Said every older generation about the younger generation ever since humans began.

And every time they said “yea but that generation is especially bad for (insert reason here)”

And it will happen to that generation as they start to wane in social relevance too.

We just need the self awareness to understand what we think about each other is not unique, it happened before and will happen again. It’s us, not them.

Although, yea, this time it’s different…🤣"

Self awareness you say?! Arrogant, condescending and ignorant. But that's okay because your wife does mindfulness.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *terag5581Man
3 weeks ago

Falkirk


"If we just all agreed to disagree, or just let things go by that we don't agree with - what kind of society would we become?"

Thanks for your input. I'll be sure to consider it, right after I finish ignoring it

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *lackbootzMan
3 weeks ago

Hayes, Middx


" … Self awareness you say?! Arrogant, condescending and ignorant. But that's okay because your wife does mindfulness... "

It’s almost as if mindful meditation hasn’t given you inner calm at all.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *wansmickMan
3 weeks ago

Belfast

More people confuse and argue opinion as if it's fact which is bound to put someone's back up.

I stay away from arguments because some people are to stupid to know their stupid ( Dunning Kruger).

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 

By *ucker4you80Man
3 weeks ago

Calne


" … Self awareness you say?! Arrogant, condescending and ignorant. But that's okay because your wife does mindfulness...

It’s almost as if mindful meditation hasn’t given you inner calm at all. "

All hail the gatekeeper, no one shall post. Just stop being a prat and let others post.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
 
 

By *ookingaroundMan
2 weeks ago

Bristol


"

Brought up wrapped in cotton wool, rarely told "no", surrounded by those who agree with them. Then unleashed into the wild. What could possibly go wrong?

Said every older generation about the younger generation ever since humans began.

And every time they said “yea but that generation is especially bad for (insert reason here)”

And it will happen to that generation as they start to wane in social relevance too.

We just need the self awareness to understand what we think about each other is not unique, it happened before and will happen again. It’s us, not them.

Although, yea, this time it’s different…🤣

Self awareness you say?! Arrogant, condescending and ignorant. But that's okay because your wife does mindfulness. "

If you have an argument against what I said, please feel free to present it.

Otherwise, carry on deflecting with ad hominem.

Reply privatelyReply in forumReply +quote
Post new Message to Thread
back to top